With the epoxide
6 in hand, the stage was set for the critical semi-pinacol rearrangement reaction. Various acidic conditions were evaluated (
Table 4). Our initial experimentation revealed that oxygen might exert a detrimental effect on this reaction. Thus, when the epoxide
6 was treated with 1 mol% TsOH in THF under an oxygen atmosphere, the desired aldehyde
5 was isolated in a scarce yield of 13%, while the two major products
11 and
7 were obtained in 39% and 43% yields, respectively (
Table 4, Entry 1). In contrast, when the reaction was run under nitrogen and otherwise identical conditions, we were able to obtain
5 as the major product in a yield 65% (
Table 4, Entry 2). Similar results were achieved with camphorsulfonic acid (CSA) in DCM (
Table 4, Entries 3, 4). We then examined boron trifluoride ethereal as the catalyst. To our delight, when
6 was treated with 0.01 equiv. of boron trifluoride ethereal in DCM under a nitrogen atmosphere,
5 was secured in 88% yield (
Table 4, Entry 5). Excellent yields of
5 were obtained at increased catalyst loadings with THF as the solvent (
Table 4, Entries 6, 7). Aldehyde
5 was converted to fenoprofen (
1) via Pinnick oxidation (
Scheme 3).